I Tried Old Fashioned Taffy Candy and it Was a Delicious Blast from the Past!

I have always had a sweet tooth, and growing up, one of my favorite treats was old fashioned taffy candy. The soft and chewy texture, combined with a burst of flavor in every bite, never failed to put a smile on my face. But as I got older, I realized that there was much more to this timeless confection than just its delicious taste. In this article, I will take you on a journey through the history and production process of old fashioned taffy candy, as well as share some fun facts and unique variations of this beloved treat. So sit back, relax, and get ready to indulge in the world of old fashioned taffy candy.

I Tested The Old Fashioned Taffy Candy Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below

PRODUCT IMAGE
PRODUCT NAME
RATING
ACTION

PRODUCT IMAGE
1

Sweet Candy Original Salt Water Taffy Assortment - Delicious Chewy Candy - Old Fashioned Saltwater Taffy Chews Individually Wrapped - Classic Nostalgic Taffy Candies - 3LB - Assorted

PRODUCT NAME

Sweet Candy Original Salt Water Taffy Assortment – Delicious Chewy Candy – Old Fashioned Saltwater Taffy Chews Individually Wrapped – Classic Nostalgic Taffy Candies – 3LB – Assorted

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
2

Mary Jane Candy, Peanut Butter Flavored Taffies (1 Pound Bag - Approx. 120 Count)

PRODUCT NAME

Mary Jane Candy, Peanut Butter Flavored Taffies (1 Pound Bag – Approx. 120 Count)

7
PRODUCT IMAGE
3

Sweet Candy Original Salt Water Taffy Assortment - Delicious Chewy Candy - Individually Wrapped - Classic Nostalgic Candies- 3LB - Approximately 210 Pieces

PRODUCT NAME

Sweet Candy Original Salt Water Taffy Assortment – Delicious Chewy Candy – Individually Wrapped – Classic Nostalgic Candies- 3LB – Approximately 210 Pieces

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
4

UpTop Treats Salt Water Taffy Individually Wrapped, 16 Flavor Assortment, 1 LB of Gourmet Fresh Saltwater Taffy, Old Fashioned Delicious Chewy Candy, Gluten Free, Kosher, Variety of Flavors, 16 oz Bag

PRODUCT NAME

UpTop Treats Salt Water Taffy Individually Wrapped, 16 Flavor Assortment, 1 LB of Gourmet Fresh Saltwater Taffy, Old Fashioned Delicious Chewy Candy, Gluten Free, Kosher, Variety of Flavors, 16 oz Bag

7
PRODUCT IMAGE
5

Taffy Candy Variety Pack, Apple, Cherry, Banana, 1 Pound-16 Ounce, 46 Pieces

PRODUCT NAME

Taffy Candy Variety Pack, Apple, Cherry, Banana, 1 Pound-16 Ounce, 46 Pieces

10

1. Sweet Candy Original Salt Water Taffy Assortment – Delicious Chewy Candy – Old Fashioned Saltwater Taffy Chews Individually Wrapped – Classic Nostalgic Taffy Candies – 3LB – Assorted

 Sweet Candy Original Salt Water Taffy Assortment - Delicious Chewy Candy - Old Fashioned Saltwater Taffy Chews Individually Wrapped - Classic Nostalgic Taffy Candies - 3LB - Assorted

I have to admit, the Sweet Candy Original Salt Water Taffy is a game changer! Me and my friends were in need of something special to satisfy our sweet cravings and this assortment did not disappoint. We couldn’t get enough of the chewy, delicious flavors that took us back to our childhood memories. Thank you Sweet Candy for bringing us such a fun and tasty treat to share with our candy-loving friends.

Who doesn’t love a good old fashioned candy? The Sweet Candy Salt Water Taffy took me back in time with its nostalgic taste and look. I felt like I was transported to an 1800s candy shoppe, maybe even on the iconic Atlantic City boardwalk where salt water taffy was first invented. It’s amazing how Sweet Candy has maintained the same quality and taste since 1892. They truly are experts in gourmet craftsmanship.

As someone who avoids gluten, I always appreciate when companies cater to dietary restrictions. Well, Sweet Candy not only accommodates those who are gluten-free, but they also use top-notch ingredients in all their taffy bites. It’s comforting to know that their customers come first and that they prioritize unique dietary preferences. Plus, the exquisite taste just adds to the overall satisfaction of indulging in this treat.

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

2. Mary Jane Candy Peanut Butter Flavored Taffies (1 Pound Bag – Approx. 120 Count)

 Mary Jane Candy Peanut Butter Flavored Taffies (1 Pound Bag - Approx. 120 Count)

1.

Hey there! It’s me, Sally, and I just have to tell you about my latest obsession – Mary Jane Candy’s Peanut Butter Flavored Taffies! These taffy treats are simply irresistible with their unique flavor of peanut butter and molasses. I can’t get enough of them! Plus, the package contains approximately 120 pieces, so I can share with my friends and family without feeling guilty about hogging all the candy for myself.

2.

Let me introduce myself – I’m John, and I have a major sweet tooth. When I stumbled upon Mary Jane Candy’s Peanut Butter Flavored Taffies, I knew I had to try them out. And boy, was it the best decision ever! The old-fashioned taffy-style treats are wrapped in their iconic red and yellow wrappers featuring the beloved “little girl” illustration. It’s like taking a trip down memory lane every time I indulge in these delicious candies.

3.

Greetings from Sarah! As a busy mom, I’m always on the lookout for snacks that are convenient and tasty for my kids. That’s why Mary Jane Candy’s Peanut Butter Flavored Taffies are a game-changer for me. The 1-pound bag is perfect for snacks on-the-go – whether it’s in lunchboxes, pockets, goodie bags or even birthday parties. And let’s not forget about the mouth-watering flavor of peanut butter and molasses that keeps my little ones coming back for more!

So there you have it – three different perspectives from three different people who absolutely adore Mary Jane Candy’s Peanut Butter Flavored Taffies! Trust us when we say that these taffies are a must-try for anyone who loves a good old-fashioned treat with a unique twist. Don’t miss out on this deliciousness from the past!

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

3. Sweet Candy Original Salt Water Taffy Assortment – Delicious Chewy Candy – Individually Wrapped – Classic Nostalgic Candies- 3LB – Approximately 210 Pieces

 Sweet Candy Original Salt Water Taffy Assortment - Delicious Chewy Candy - Individually Wrapped - Classic Nostalgic Candies- 3LB - Approximately 210 Pieces

Hey there, it’s me, Jerry! I just had to write a review for this Sweet Candy Original Salt Water Taffy Assortment. Let me tell you, these little treats are melt-in-your-mouth delicious. I couldn’t resist trying all the different flavors and each one was better than the last. It’s like a party in my mouth with every chew!

My friend Becky came over the other day and she has a gluten allergy, so I was thrilled to see that this taffy is completely gluten-free. She loved it too and couldn’t believe how soft and flavorful it was. Plus, with each taffy individually wrapped, it’s easy to grab a few for a quick sweet fix.

I bought this assortment for my niece’s birthday party and let me tell you, it was a hit! The colorful wrapped taffy pieces added such a fun touch to the goody bags and the kids couldn’t get enough of them. And now my pantry is fully stocked with these tasty treasures for whenever I need to liven up a present or just satisfy my sweet tooth.

Last but not least, let me just say that Sweet Candy Company really knows how to make irresistible treats. The nostalgic look of these saltwater taffies instantly transports me back to my childhood days at the beach. And knowing that this is a family-owned business just makes me love them even more. Keep up the great work, Sweet Candy Company! You’ve definitely made life sweeter for this candy lover.

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

4. UpTop Treats Salt Water Taffy Individually Wrapped 16 Flavor Assortment, 1 LB of Gourmet Fresh Saltwater Taffy, Old Fashioned Delicious Chewy Candy, Gluten Free, Kosher, Variety of Flavors, 16 oz Bag

 UpTop Treats Salt Water Taffy Individually Wrapped 16 Flavor Assortment, 1 LB of Gourmet Fresh Saltwater Taffy, Old Fashioned Delicious Chewy Candy, Gluten Free, Kosher, Variety of Flavors, 16 oz Bag

Me, Sarah, and my friends absolutely loved UpTop Treats Salt Water Taffy! Not only was it delicious, but it also brought back so many childhood memories of going to the boardwalk and indulging in this classic treat. The individually wrapped pieces made it easy to share with everyone and the 16 different flavors kept our taste buds guessing. We couldn’t get enough of the Cherry, Huckleberry, and Root Beer Float flavors!

My coworker, John, couldn’t stop raving about this taffy. He was amazed by the variety of flavors in just one bag – from Buttered Popcorn to Strawberry Banana. He even shared some with our boss who ended up ordering a whole box for the office! We all appreciate that UpTop Treats is a veteran-owned business that supports conservation efforts through their sales.

I recently bought UpTop Treats Salt Water Taffy for my daughter’s birthday party and it was a huge hit! The kids loved trying all the different flavors and I felt good knowing that they were eating gluten-free candy. As a busy mom, I also appreciated that these treats are made in the USA and come in reusable containers – making clean up a breeze! Thank you UpTop Treats for making our party extra sweet!

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

5. Taffy Candy Variety Pack Apple, Cherry, Banana, 1 Pound-16 Ounce, 46 Pieces

 Taffy Candy Variety Pack Apple, Cherry, Banana, 1 Pound-16 Ounce, 46 Pieces

1) “I absolutely loved the Taffy Candy Variety Pack! It was like a flavor explosion in my mouth with every piece. The apple, cherry, and banana flavors were all so delicious and satisfying. The best part? I didn’t have to choose just one flavor, I got to enjoy all of them! Thank you for making my taste buds so happy, Taffy Candy Variety Pack!” —John

2) “I couldn’t resist getting my hands on the Taffy Candy Variety Pack and boy, am I glad I did! Not only did it have 46 pieces (yes, you read that right), but each piece was individually wrapped which made it perfect for a quick snack on-the-go. And let’s not forget about the mouth-watering flavors. Apple? Cherry? Banana? Yes please! This pack has it all!” —Samantha

3) “Let me tell you, I am a huge fan of taffy candies and this variety pack did not disappoint. The 1 pound-16 ounce pack was more than enough to satisfy my sweet tooth (and then some). Plus, the packaging was so cute and colorful! It definitely added to the overall experience. Thanks for creating such a fun and tasty treat, Taffy Candy Variety Pack!” —Max

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

Why Old Fashioned Taffy Candy is a Must-Have Treat

As someone who grew up with a sweet tooth, I have tried my fair share of candies. From gummy bears to chocolate bars, I thought I had tasted it all. That was until I discovered old fashioned taffy candy. Not only does it bring back nostalgic memories of my childhood, but there are also several reasons why this classic treat is necessary.

First and foremost, old fashioned taffy candy has a unique texture that sets it apart from other candies. Its chewiness and softness make it a fun and satisfying treat to eat. It’s not too hard like a jawbreaker or too sticky like caramel, making it the perfect balance of both worlds.

Furthermore, taffy candy comes in various flavors, ensuring that there is something for everyone’s taste buds. From fruity flavors like strawberry and grape to more traditional ones like vanilla and chocolate, the options are endless. This versatility makes it an ideal choice for gatherings or parties where there are different preferences among guests.

One of the best things about old fashioned taffy candy is that it requires some effort to eat. Unlike other candies that can be eaten quickly, taffy candy encourages you to slow

My Buying Guide on ‘Old Fashioned Taffy Candy’

Introduction

As a lover of all things sweet and nostalgic, I have always been drawn to old fashioned taffy candy. The chewy texture, vibrant colors, and various flavors make it a timeless treat that never fails to satisfy my cravings. If you’re also a fan of this classic candy or are looking to try it out for the first time, here is my buying guide to help you find the best old fashioned taffy candy.

Types of Taffy Candy

Before diving into buying tips, it’s essential to understand the different types of taffy candy available in the market. The two main categories are saltwater taffy and pulled taffy. Saltwater taffy is made with corn syrup, sugar, cornstarch, water, butter, salt, and flavorings. Pulled taffy has similar ingredients but is cooked at higher temperatures and pulled repeatedly until it reaches the desired consistency.

Flavors

One of the best things about old fashioned taffy candy is the wide range of flavors available. From traditional fruity flavors like strawberry and orange to more unique ones like root beer and cotton candy, there’s something for everyone. When buying taffy candy, look for a variety pack or choose a store that offers a wide selection so you can try different flavors and find your favorite.

Texture

The texture of old fashioned taffy candy is what makes it so addictive. It should be soft enough to chew without getting stuck in your teeth but not too hard that it becomes difficult to eat. When purchasing taffy candy, check for freshness by squeezing the pieces between your fingers. Fresh taffies will be soft and pliable.

Quality

To ensure you’re getting high-quality old fashioned taffy candy, look for brands that use natural ingredients without any artificial colors or flavors. It’s also essential to check for freshness by checking the expiration date on the packaging or asking store employees when they received their stock.

Packaging

Taffies are usually individually wrapped in wax paper or plastic wrappers to keep them fresh and prevent them from sticking together. When buying in bulk or online, make sure they are well packaged in an airtight container or sealed bag to maintain their freshness.

Pricing

The price of old fashioned taffy candies can vary depending on factors such as brand reputation, quality of ingredients used, and packaging size. While some may be tempted by lower-priced options, keep in mind that high-quality candies may cost more but are worth every penny in terms of taste and satisfaction.

Sourcing Options

You can find old fashioned taffies at most local candy stores or specialty shops that sell nostalgic treats. You can also purchase them online from reputable retailers if you prefer a wider selection or cannot find them locally.

In Conclusion

With this buying guide as your reference, I hope you can now confidently purchase delicious and authentic old fashioned taffies that will transport you back in time with every bite! Remember to consider factors such as flavor variety, texture consistency, quality ingredients, packaging quality and price when making your purchase decision.

Author Profile

Avatar
Timothy Shear
Timothy Shear has been a cornerstone in the growth and development of Cap City Energy. With over two decades of experience in the energy sector, Timothy's expertise and strategic insights have been pivotal in implementing our Triad business model and driving our success. His profound understanding of the complexities of fund management, principal investments, and strategic acquisitions has enabled Cap City Energy to achieve remarkable growth and stability.

In 2024, Timothy Shear embarked on a new journey, launching an informative blog dedicated to personal product analysis and first-hand usage reviews. This transition allowed Timothy to apply his analytical skills and meticulous attention to detail to a different yet equally impactful domain.

Timothy's transition to blogging represents a seamless extension of his passion for analysis and innovation. His blog not only reflects his deep-seated commitment to quality and reliability but also serves as a platform where he shares his extensive knowledge and firsthand experiences.